DISCLAIMER

>> Sunday, November 21, 2010

Evenings like last night remind me sharply of the disparity between my reality and the persona I may unintentionally present online, in this space here where I ruminate and reflect, sharing my favorite photos to evoke a feeling or sentiment, or just to illustrate the boyfulness of my life. Occasionally I get emails from a reader or a comment from a faraway friend who reads my blog telling me 'what a great mom' I am. While I appreciate support and think, in general, that people should express kind words towards each other more often, I cringe a little when I get these kudos for my mothering. Because frankly -- I feel a little fraudulent.

To clear things up, I offer up now a little disclaimer: I, for one, most certainly do not have my shit together.

I love mothering, I enjoy most every aspect of it, and frankly I think I do a pretty good job overall. But I have plenty of faults and flaws and insecurities. For starters: I yell too much, I'm always late, I tend toward laziness, I'm terrible at returning calls and emails, my house is always messy, I'm the only mother on the east side of Madison who has kids that won't eat raw vegetables straight from the garden without coercion. (Or dip. Lots and lots of dip.)

And my kids are crazy. While this is in no way a fault or even a complaint, it is occasionally a source of insecurity. I have three very physical, very loud, very active boys and when we venture out to parties and potlucks and events, they are still physical and loud and active. Inevitably, raucous devolves into mayhem, often resulting in wrestling, spinning, or random and unintentional kicks to someone's face. Even among the most supportive and understanding of crowds (like last night, at our beloved semi-annual preschool art show and stone soup party) I walk away feeling slightly deflated, wondering if silent judgment passed through the minds of friends and acquaintances, or whether I left anyone baffled by my seeming ineptitude in the child-control department. My exhaustion and doubts climb their way to a seat of power, stepping on the heads and slouching shoulders of my confidence and intuition. Is this just how it is with three kids? With three boys? Or is it me?

Point being - I'm not perfect. Anyone who knows me in person or finds themselves in my company for more than 2o minutes can attest to this. (Or you could ask my family and they'll tell you sight unseen....) We measure ourselves against the best of another mother, rather than the whole. It is a dangerous path to tread because we will never measure up to the composite of the best of every other mother.

In these online spaces where we select which pieces of the whole to share, which stories to tell, what photos to post, it is easy to give the impression of having it all together. Which I don't. And I just wanted to make that clear.

So to you - far away friends and online strangers - especially the new mamas among you -- please remember not to hold yourself in comparison to the facade you perceive as the ideal, the Perfect Mother -- here or on other blogs or at the grocery store or in the school pick up line. Because she doesn't exist. I'm not her, you're not her. (There is no Her.)

Thus ends my public service announcement.

I wrote a little piece last week on my struggle with ambition and passion and faith over at In the Hush of the Moon. I wax a bit poetic, so if that's not your thing I did leave a bit more of an explanation in the comments. The post is here if you'd like to read it.

And finally, for a little glimpse into the chaos that is my daily life, here's a little clip (below) from a perfectly normal, run of the mill evening in the Clarity-Chaos Household. Watch, then please tell me - in all honesty -- is this level of volume and activity the norm in your house too? Does it seem so MUCH just because our house is tiny? Am I scaring you away from having more children?

Oh, and be sure to head over on Tuesday to good tots! a new blog "for stylish moms and their kids" by my friend Jill of the inspirational fashion/style blog good life for less. She'll be publishing a piece I wrote for her mom says series where I share my top five mantras for mothering. Please check it out if you have a minute!

Over and out friends. Have a fabulous Thanksgiving.


note the minivan captains chair masquerading as furniture. and the sweet dog, immune to the mayhem.

36 comments:

Anonymous,  November 21, 2010 at 10:12 PM  

OK, OK, point taken! but I have had an insider view and have witnessed how many times in a day you say "I love you" and I stand by my words.

Laura November 21, 2010 at 10:42 PM  

This is wonderful, lovely chaos inspired by love, and I love it! I've had it, I've been there and I'm on the other side -- and I miss it, dear girl.

I also love the fact that Dad has his own personal light saber.

Anonymous,  November 21, 2010 at 10:52 PM  

Thank you for this. I yell at sofia when I get stressed, which is a lot of the time because I do the difficult bath to bed routine day in and day out after a day of law school. I worry so much how my yelling will affect her, short and long term...and it is embarassing to me for my husband to see me act so badly. Sometimes I am so impatient, I just want to scream. (Well, that's when I do...) so its good to know that I am not alone. It is so important to mommies everywhere to chip away at the perfect mommy myth...no one talks about it, at least not enough. Thanks again for bearing your vulnerabilities so generously. - gillian

Daniegirl November 21, 2010 at 10:53 PM  

Thanks for the reminder. :) It's easy to get sucked into the glossiness of blog world and make those comparisons. I do wonder from time to time if my favorite reads lives are really as wonderful and perfect as they seem to be.

"Is this just how it is with three kids? With three boys? Or is it me?"

My smallest two are boys and they are crazy. Running, climbing, punching each other. Crazy. It's def not just you and I am guessing it's not just us?

Rachel November 21, 2010 at 11:08 PM  

Hi. I love reading your blog. 3 boys = craziness. The new apartment we are in has doors to the hallway that are not so sound proof. Sometimes I wonder what my neighbors think...fighting, screaming (from both the boys and me), the boys play fighting (they call it struggling and has its own set of rules), doors slamming, boys talking very loudly...sometimes I wish the door was thicker but I am glad it is not because that little social pressure of a thin door and neighbors who might be overhearing helps me to check myself when I get frustrated (which is often).

Anastasia,  November 22, 2010 at 4:32 AM  

I love that you give your kids permission to be themselves! I have also seen how much love you dole out to those honeys - they will make wonderful men someday! Thanks for sharing, I struggle in the comparison department all the time! I'm all for squashing the "perfect mommy" myth too!

Cristina November 22, 2010 at 6:16 AM  

your house? just like mine! except that I only have two boys. but it's still chaos all the time... and so I find myself yelling a lot.. and then I feel guilty.
I know we only get a limited view of you here but your attitude and beliefs come across and they show what type of mom you are :)

Tessa November 22, 2010 at 8:56 AM  

love it. your house does NOT seem over the top crazy, in fact that horse play seemed a bit mellow....not sure what that says for MY house.
Love the noises coming out of the little ones mouth as he "shings" the light saber.

meganboley.com November 22, 2010 at 10:52 AM  

OK. Thank you for posting this. It is good to read as a new mom.

Secondly, I think I am crazy, because that video still makes me want more boys.

Thirdly, your dog must be up for sainthood. What a love.

Corinne November 22, 2010 at 10:58 AM  

YES!
Are you in my brain? Because last night I was laying in bed thinking I wanted to post a very similar post. I feel really icky when people comment on my mothering (in a good way... because people don't come to my blog and say "YOU'RE A TERRIBLE MOTHER!!" who would do that?) because there are so many moments where my mothering is sub par. Where there's yelling, and kids running like crazy (seriously, my kids would fit right in with your kids) and screaming and yelling and so in the moment that it's almost frightening.
Anyway, I could ramble on... but just know that I absolutely adore this post. And you.

Jill GG (good life for less) November 22, 2010 at 11:24 AM  

Amen sister! And I love the reminder... and need it often. We are all doing our best - there is no such thing as perfection in motherhood.

The Empress November 22, 2010 at 11:26 AM  

Hey, don't remember how I found you, I think it was through Life Without Pink.

I am the mother of 3 boys, and I love the chaos...I truly do.

Pleasure to meet you, and I love your honesty in this post.

deb November 22, 2010 at 1:38 PM  

I'd babysit in a heartbeat first of all. They are perfectly wonderfully adorable. I'll make sure my husband and son are home so they could show off their fighting skills. And it might spark a spice girls concert for old times sake by my daughters. At the same time. You know , it's all about making joyful noise!

I plead for grace for many of those little one days. And the tween days. And the I went back to work days. And the teen and the adult vs the adult and ....

I used to obsess over keeping my kids in line in public and I hope they forget my shameful wrath.

Kristen @ Motherese November 22, 2010 at 2:38 PM  

A great big YES to this post!

It's sometimes easy as a mother to live life in the comparative register, weighing our own realities against what we perceive to be the more perfect normals of friends and strangers.

One of the things I really value about my blogging friends is their willingness to show the ways in which they don't always do the right things, but usually try to do what's best in the moment. I need that honest conversation and thank you for continuing it here today.

xo

Meghan November 22, 2010 at 3:49 PM  

Your honesty is admirable. And the video? I love Daddy's lazy-casual light saber skills; and what I see in that video is freedom and fun. And if you can stay curled up on the couch, out of the way when you feel you need to, (and be ready for snuggles when they need it) then more power to you, sister!
We're not at the point of chaos in our home...yet. We'll see what baby #2 brings! Love you! I think you make me a better mom just by setting the examples you do - of being open, of seeing the beauty and unique qualities of your kids, of sharing your joys and your struggles.

slouchy November 22, 2010 at 8:13 PM  

I yell too much, I'm always late, I tend toward laziness, I'm terrible at returning calls and emails, my house is always messy, I'm the only mother on the east side of Madison who has kids that won't eat raw vegetables straight from the garden without coercion.

Wait. Are you me?

Looks just like the chaos at my house...

Ann Imig November 22, 2010 at 9:18 PM  

I stand by Anonymous' comment (the first one) She sounds like she knows what she's talking about.

Alison,  November 23, 2010 at 8:44 AM  

I loved this piece and the video especially. Beautiful chaos!

Sarah November 23, 2010 at 9:14 AM  

THIS IS MY LIFE.

Yes, we encourage the 2-year-old to sharpen his sword-wielding skills. How on earth will he ever keep up if we don't start him now?

I have folders full of videos JUST LIKE THIS on my computer. In fact, I think I'm going to send you one or two when I can FIND THE TIME because YOU ARE IN MY HEAD with every word you wrote here and THIS VIDEO IS MY LIFE (and it gets a WHOLE LOT CRAZIER THAN EVEN THIS, right?) and I LOVE YOU TO DEATH FOR THIS POST.

How's that for an ENTHUSIASTIC comment? (Don't you just hate ALL CAPS?!)

xo

Sarah

Amanda November 23, 2010 at 9:48 AM  

Our three girls are loud and seem to emanate glitter and ribbons from their very pores. There is fatigue, frustration and anger. But oh, there is so much beauty in chaos.

Misty November 23, 2010 at 12:50 PM  

um, yes?!?!
i, too, have 3 boys a bit younger in age than yours, but all 17 mo apart and one on the way. tempers are short and noise threshold is low and that doesn't matter when you're 4, almost 3 and 1. they.don't.care.
:)
we are a Crazy household too. i love my boys but they drive me nuts, too. i think it is all part of the territory of having littles.

i love that you shared this. b/cs it's real. so very real.

Michelle Galyardt November 23, 2010 at 4:17 PM  

I heard about your blog from Sarah at Momalom after searching the web for fellow mothers of 3 boys. I have a 6 yr old, a 4 yr old and a 17 month old all boys and have to say that I have never commented because you did seem to have your shit together better than I. I appreciate your honesty and have to say that your video is in no way shocking to me!!! In fact, they looked a little mellow to me. There was really no violence, crying, or threats of violence. I also wanted to say that I definitely yell too much as well. It is so easy to get caught up in the intensity of these little testosterone factories. Anyhow, I don't know you and yet as a fellow mother, I support you!
Michelle

Elizabeth @claritychaos November 23, 2010 at 7:27 PM  

Ok, I am laughing at all of you who are saying this seems relatively mellow compared to your houses because after I uploaded, I felt a little sheepish knowing that this is a pretty moderate level of chaos. I just didn't feel I could post a full-on rambunctious scream/cry/punch fest. Trust me - those happen. But this video shows the good side of normal - the chaos level when everything is going smoothly. Notice it's only 1 minute long... ;)

Alex@LateEnough November 23, 2010 at 7:57 PM  

love the dog in the video. hilarious. i kinda feel like that one some days.

Mary November 23, 2010 at 8:38 PM  

Love this post! I linked over here fro momalon and am so glad I did. I'm totally taking the button to put on my blog as well. I only have 2 but still very busy boys. 8 and 3 and I think they are both going to have a future in the WWF. I'll be back for sure.

Marilyn (A Lot of Loves) November 24, 2010 at 1:34 AM  

I feel the same. I've received the same "you're a good mom" comments and yet most of the time I feel like I'm not measuring up to my own ideals. I have a sneaking suspicion that this is a feeling shared among many.

Christine November 24, 2010 at 6:22 AM  

We need to be honest and up front like this more often, if only to understand how normal it is. If only to hear from others that the life a mother is a constant scale of chaos. Good days, bad days, crazy days. They all matter in their own way. I recently had conversation with someone who reminded me that in these years far less matters than we think it might, and as long as the house is full of love all will work. I believe that. And I'm certain that you spare lots of hugs and kisses and cuddles. To me that's really what moms are for.

There is much I would like to say to this, but I won't comandeer your comments. But I will add that there are only two little boys in my house and I can assure you that this is very familiar.
xo

Rudri November 24, 2010 at 1:08 PM  

I over from Momalom and glad I came to visit. This post resonates with me on so many levels. I think people assume you are your blog. We still live messy and complicated lives like everyone else, with hints of happiness, laughter and love.

Shawna Cevraini November 24, 2010 at 1:17 PM  

Thanks for the honesty in this post and yes, we all (yes ALL) compare ourselves to others.

It doesn't get much quieter after they get older as I just had a weekend with the 11 year old dd that had a sleepover with 6 of her friends. OMG - LOUD doesn't even cover it!

I also have 10 and 20 year old boys. The 20 year old can still get rowdy with his siblings and friends (hubby instigates a lot of that too! Big kid that he is)

I am far from a perfect mother and find myself comparing to the PERFECT one far, far too often.

However, the 20 year old has served to remind me more and more lately that all too soon they won't be around anymore and it will be way too quiet and I won't be able to yell at anyone. It humbles me and helps me to "chill" and enjoy more.

And reading posts like this one, helps me more than you know. Thank you!

krista November 24, 2010 at 2:11 PM  

girl, if you had your shit together, i'm not sure we could be friends. because then you would always be making me feel bad.
xoxo
note to self: it's time to teach finn sword-fighting. with the spin included. genius.

Bella November 24, 2010 at 8:21 PM  

You're Awesome :0)

I enjoy reading your posts! Thanks for making me smile again. I definitely needed it today.

michelle November 25, 2010 at 9:17 PM  

thanks for these words! I've been sitting on something similiar for a while. I keep finding people who seem to be disappointed with the real life version of me compared to the online one! Edited and Chosen is not the same as real.

Allison @ Alli 'n Son November 26, 2010 at 1:46 PM  

I think there so many moms are exactly like you (and me for that matter). It's so nice to hear someone admit it. I do my best to be honest about my parenting mistakes on my blog, but I don't share everything. People sometimes forget that what the read on a blog is just a snapshot of life. There's so much more that we don't write about.

Jennifer Fink November 27, 2010 at 10:49 AM  

Completely, completely normal! As you know, I have 4 boys, so it anything, life is probably even louder and more chaotic at my house. And like you, I struggle with how their behavior is perceived by others and wonder at times if it reflects poorly on me,on my parenting skills. But my boys are boys, are while I won't use that as an excuse for bad behavior, I'm also not going to force them to sit silently for hours at a time when that's not who they are.

Maria November 29, 2010 at 7:55 PM  

Amen to that sister! She is a facade, this perfect mother. And as for the noise level, my boys are much louder. Perhaps because they are half Cuban, and we operate at several octaves louder!

Glad to know I am not the only one ;)!

Only You December 8, 2010 at 2:26 PM  

I can so relate to everything you wrote here, down to every single "flaw" that you listed (the only difference is that I don't live near Madison ;-)). I also have wondered about the disparity between the real 24/7 3D me versus the blog me.

I just saw love and fun in your video, and I did love the calmness of both your dog and husband!

Post a Comment

tell me your stories. or just say hi. i like to know you're here. :)

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Clarity in the Chaos

I'm a realistic optimist who relies on raw honesty and plenty of humor to navigate the boystorm that is my life. I am mother to three and wife to one. These are my stories.


Finding clarity in the chaos since 2009.
All rights reserved.

  © Blogger template Webnolia by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP