(one for all the new mamas out there)
>> Tuesday, August 24, 2010
Owen has his first sleepover this week. He's so excited - he has his special stuffed giraffe packed, he'll bring his water bottle and his pillows and his sleeping bag.
What I would give to press my ear to that wall, to crouch outside a door cracked, to listen through vents at the back and forth between two buddies. One seven, and mine turning seven in a week.
When Owen was a baby, people asked me why I never put him down, wondered why I held him non-stop, whether he lived in that sling, didn't I want to foster independence?
I told them this is how we do things, this is how we like it. I had to answer that a lot.
He was a cautious kid, even from the start. Cautious and observant, wide-eyed from birth, taking it all in, more than many realized. He felt most comfortable, happiest, most secure on my hip or in my arms. He rarely cried as a baby, and when he'd start, I'd go to him, no matter who was holding him or where we were.
"He's fine." "Let him fuss." "I've got him," they'd say, turning slightly away with my baby. And I'd politely insist (or ignore) and I'd pick him up or take him back and he'd stop, back with Mama where all is right.
I knew what he needed, what he wanted, even when no one else saw it. When they quite possibly (probably) saw a young, controlling, new mother -- I stuck to my gut, my heart, and I did what I knew my baby needed.
As a toddler, he never ventured far. At the park with friends, other two year olds would escape the parental grip and flee, free to roam and climb and play. But my boy would happily sit with me, my lap his perch, for the entirety of the playdate, only venturing across junglegym bridges and down slides with his hand wrapped in mine. He wasn't afraid, he just didn't want to explore alone.
"Doesn't he want to play?" "Well someone's a mama's boy." "He's going to have to learn to leave your side at some point." I'd smile and nod. Yep. At some point.
We were a team, a package deal. I heard many well-meaning (and plenty of mean) comments about needing to let him go, to encourage his independence, to push him to try things on his own. I heard that this was all because I held him too much. Because I never put him down. Because he lived in that sling.
But I let it slide. I knew my child. Who he was, what he needed. And I didn't see the rush in pushing him away, in placing a disproportionate weight on the virtue of independence.
He was close to his dad, too; and to his babysitter when we were at work or class. But he continued to shy away from crowds of kids. He'd rather lay claim to a quieter space, one with plenty of room. He didn't like being crammed into close proximity with a cluster of kids, had no interest in joining a group activity. He had a big personal bubble, and he'd rather hang back and watch than participate.
He was an early talker, and he felt more secure talking with adults. If a grown up walked towards him while he held a ball, he knew they understood him when he told them it was his. But when another two year old approached, arms flailing, babbling excitedly, he grew scared and frustrated that they didn't understand his little sentences: "This is my ball. I don't want you to take it." And he'd freak.
Years passed, preschool and playdates continued, and the kid-to-kid communication gap shrunk. And in his own time, this boy became more comfortable with elbows bumping, with clusters and groups. Bit by bit he ventured further, running across parks and playgrounds, but always coming back to check in, to refuel with a snuggle from his mama, and I was always there waiting with open arms and a spot on my lap.
And then kindergarten: a teacher, a class, a school, a bus. A half-block walk home on his own, feet skipping and backpack bouncing. He makes new friends everywhere he goes -- at the park, the pool, the playground. He waits in line, he takes his turn, he jumps feet first and arms to the sky, straight into the boy-piles of life.
We never forced it. We never rushed him. We never worried. Even when other people did, when they thought we should.
There is no one way to do it. There is no ideal timeline for independence. There is your child. And his own needs. And his own self. Honor it. Trust your heart. And your gut. Be firm but polite. (Or not-so-polite, if need be.)
Because we are the ones who know our children best. Who know what's best for our children.
He's turning seven next week, and he's going on his first sleepover. He's so excited - he can't wait to venture off. He'll bring his stuffed giraffe, and his pillow. They'll stay up late and talk and giggle hard from inside sleeping bags, behind doors cracked.
And we'll be here when he's ready to come home.


34 comments:
this?
is why i heart you.
I have heard this numerous times since Brice was born. "Why don't you put him down?" And I keep thinking, why would I? Like Owen, he rarely cries. Like you, I know what he needs. And someday he's going to grow up, and I will look back and know I held him more than enough.
I love this. My oldest is very similar to yours. I don't believe in letting babies tough it out. Like you I held, a lot, coslept and all... boy the comments about that. But now at almost 4 he isn't afraid of trying anything and I believe that security he feels comes from knowing that I am right there, everytime.
Thanks, Elizabeth. With only three months to go until I become a mother, you have made me remember that I need to make the choices that are best for my child, even if it is not always the popular opinion. Although I haven't seen you since Owen was a baby, through your words I know what a great mother you are. Thanks for sharing your experiences.
A beautiful, heartfelt reminder. What surprised me the most is how strong my intuition was, even after a muddled first few months. I think the instinct bubbles up, and the real task is to simply trust it and hear it. Thank you for this. xox
beautifully written, as always from you. this post is a gift to other mothers -- new and seasoned! my eldest must have been cut from a similar mold -- this could be her story.
I'm so nervous for you! HA! But we are so much alike in this.
(Also, I was told "he'll never learn to walk if you're always carrying him" and Gray was my earliest walker at 11 months so there.)
Steph
PS what I really should have said first was:
I really love this post.
Steph
What a sweet post!!! I understand how you feel, I too carry my little one a lot, they are always close to me, but our little girls are very independent and real social butterflies LOL
I think just because I did wear them so much that they learn very young that Mama is always going to be there for them so they are not afraid to leave my side (but that is just their personalities and all babies are different :-)
enjoyed this post. and your profile picture. i have three boys [4,2,0] and often my photos that include me look like that.
http://curiousgeorgi.blogspot.com/
Love this post. You inspired my 25 week post - http://swollenwithideas.tumblr.com/post/1009103679/dear-peanut
Thanks for the gift of words, as always.
This is so eloquent. They all grow so quickly. I look at each day as one and enjoy it to its fullest. But as I look back over the past 9 years with kids in my house I can't believe how quickly they have passed.
Last night we went on a walk. My 5 year old, C, didn't want to come. So I scooped him up on my back in his pjs and bare toes and we headed out the door. I received some funny looks from passersby as C's long legs dangled at my side. He made it about 5 minutes before he wriggled out of my arms. He skipped, ran and laughed and decided to take the long way home. These moments are so precious. They each spread their wings as they are ready.
A big resounding YES!
"in his own time" - that's so key.
You are a beautiful mama. Good job :)
This is so well timed for me...my son is about to turn one and oh how I've been snuggling this kid for the last 11 months! This past weekend at a friends house, he was clearly nervous and clingy, and that mama part of me just loved that all he wanted to do was hang on. Someone said, kindly, (but, you know...)"no wonder he's not walking yet, he gets a free ride everywhere!" and I wanted to be mean to them, but I just smiled and smelled the top of his head. But of course I've wondered since then, because he does love hanging close to us, and reading this today reminded me that my kid, my perfect, charming, wonderful kid, is right on schedule. And one day he's going to go to a sleepover and I'm going to think, "he's so big, I wish that I had held him a little longer when he still fit in my arms". Thanks for sharing!
you have to do what works for your own family.
I held my babies when they were young, constantly, always got "feedback" .
you are honouring the child that is gifted to you... that's never wrong.
I have silently disagreed on what another mother does as her normal, but it's not my relationship.
It is and forever will be yours.
beautiful.
here's to a night of big things for your Owen. I hope your phone doesn't rinng, but if it does it shows he trusts you.
There is no one right way to do this thing. I have come to figure that out after nearly 8 years of this mommy thing. I wish I could go back and tell my new-mommy self that. I did so many things b/c I thought I had to. And I was pretty inflexible. Thankfully my kids have survived my failures. God made them flexible. :)
this is fresh air.
crisp, and cold.
i know my children too. and i hold them close. in this overseas military life, daycare is sometimes looked at as a must. and i disagree...
i want my babies home with me.
beautiful words. they sting deep, and heal deeper.
:)
What a great testimony to a mom's self-confidence! More of us need a dose of that. (I always say, "Be your own mom!")
@togetherforgood you are so right - and that's SO important to emphasize: they are flexible. they are resilient. and we are human. <3
thanks for reading everyone, and for sharing your own mini-stories. I love reading them.
Oh my, YES! I've written on this very topic several times as I've watched my once-clingy-high-needs firstborn bloom and blossom and grow into Miss Independence. You have said it so much more powerfully and beautifully than I ever have. Lots of enthusiastic nodding and clapping over here!
This Mommy of two super cool comfortable wide -eyed boys (26mo. & 10mo) thanks you for sharing!
Really need to get back to my blog, someday.
Ann
I stumbled on this post and I want you to know I am your newest fan! We also practice attachment parenting (I don't mind one bit that my 15-month old fits so perfectly against me as we cuddle to sleep.) I am sorry for all those lame people who said non-encouraging things to you. My son River who just turned 4 was a different personality than your son you described, he has always been adventurous. Little Rue is a little more "I want this from you NOW MOM", and is attached to me always.
Thanks for the post...I look forward to more!
I love this! Will be bookmarking your blog as I have two small boys of my own and I can just imagine that picture up there will be me someday. :)
Thank you.
elizabeth, this resonates, as ever. we are still newish (2yrs, does that qualify as new anymore?) to texas and so we don't have a lot of friends, and the one mom i met at mops last year and we get together sometimes... well, it's like we speak two languages (which we do, i suppose): she can't fathom why i hold avery so much at 13 mo and why i don' tmind that connor (2, like her son) is just as at home in my lap as he is off scampering. she thinks i've defiled my marriage bed w/ cosleeping and she has fortunately held her tongue on my position on spanking, but i definitely know hers.
it's hard to be so opposite to real life people and be so like minded w/ virtual friends, yet, i'm so glad to know that i'm not alone in all this. i wish i'd read this reminder when my oldest was still young and my arms were sore w/ teh holding and yet i still clung b/cs i just had to.
That was lovely! The thread through all the stories I've read about what works, for all the varied authors? Respect.
Respect your child, respect your gut instinct, respect other mamas' choices that are different from your own. And by doing so, you're teaching your kid to do it too.
Wonderfully said!!!! You are one fabulous mom:)
So many times I heard that if I didn't let B cry it out she would never sleep on her own, never learn to self sooth. Well she never cried it out and she did learn to go to sleep on her own and she did learn to self sooth. Like you said in her own time!
my goodness i love this. once again you've written something i feel like i've written in my head while half asleep but never typed out. yep, yep, and yep.
I 100% agree and I think the concept of "attachment parenting" has given mothers a platform to stand on when it comes to nay-sayers. I wish people would understand that every mother has the right to do her things HER way, isnt that what makes our children unique? LOVE this post!
Your son as a toddler sounds so very much like my 2.5 year old son. I'm not pushing him to go out on his own. When he's ready, he will do it on his own. I can't and won't make him do it if he's not ready.
We need to trust ourselves as mothers who know what is best for our kids. And ignore everything else.
You know I agree with you.
They're all so different. My second was more adventurous and less observant, less needing me to hold his hand through life. And the baby? He was like 'see ya later, ma!' from the start. He comes back to refuel, always. But he's been trailing his brothers' heels from the get go.
They're all so different, and I think the key is just honoring those differences.
Thank you for all the great comments and stories. You guys are great.
a to the men.
this is a wonderful post. you are so right--each babe is different, and mamas (even brand new mamas!) know their babes best.
meeting your child's needs and babywearing are fantastic practices--i don't understand why we're always encouraged to separate and ignore.
Thanks for sharing this. I applaud you for being so confident, for knowing, and for sticking up for your son and your values. It's unbelievable how entitled others feel about unloading their judgments on others, isn't it?
My son is half a year younger than yours, and for cultural reasons he still sleeps in our room. Different beds but the same room. He's questioned us about why he would need to sleep alone - he says, "Why do you get to sleep with someone but I'm supposed to sleep by myself?"
We want to encourage him to feel ready to have his own room, but we are not rushing or pushing it. He's incredibly social, adaptable and independent, and this he proved by moving to a new country and adapting so well to the different schools he's had to attend. I too am not worried.
Post a Comment